Lecture Notes
(from Instructor's Manual by Ronald J. Schwartz, J.D., L.L.M.
for textbook
Law and Aging - Essentials of Elder Law - 1st Edition - Pearson
Publications)
The Patient's Rights in Healthcare Decision
Making
Topical Outline
a. Three Typical Case Scenarios
b. Core Issues
(1) An individual's liberty rights pursuant
to the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
(2) The state's paramount interest to prevent
suicide and keep patients alive under any condition
(3) The medical profession's dedication to sustaining
life
c. Landmark Cases
d.. Physician-assisted suicide
e. Position of the U.S. Supreme Court on a patient's right to
die, as of June, 1997
Learning Objectives
a. to learn about the U.S. Constitution's 14th amendment protection
of an individual's liberty rights, in connection with patient
self-determination
b. to read and interpret the major landmark cases in the area,
such as, In re: Quinlan, 1976, O'Connor v. Westchester
County Hospital, 1988 and Cruzan v. Director Missouri Department
of Health, 1991.
c. to understand the current theories on physician-assisted suicide
in the United States, including those of Jack Kevorkian, M.D.
Job Competencies
a. to draft healthcare advance decision making instruments
b. to be able to assist the client in executing healthcare decision
making documents
c. to understand how to help a client in the event that no advance
directives have been executed
d. to develop relationships with healthcare professionals, such
as nurses, psychiatrists, gerontologists and social workers
Key Concepts
Many clients are confronted with problems for which there are
no simple solutions. These problems call for crisis intervention
or deal with issues of declining quality of life due to degenerative
and catastrophic illnesses or imminent mortality. Professionals
in this area must have the ability to deal with life-and-death
situations on a daily basis. They must learn how to be compassionate,
while remaining objective in order to best serve their clients.
The major focus of the elder care law practice is to represent
clients and their families in planning for and during the end
of life. The legal professional must be willing to deal with these
problems daily.